Revisiting the Promotion / Relegation ‘Hamilton Plan’ for Washington

Editor’s Preface: Over three years ago Timothy Hamilton shared not only  a dream but a plan for adult men’s soccer in the state of Washington. As Hamilton was using his graphic talents in helping to launch the Evergreen Premier League (he designed the EPLWA logo) his mind was on what dreams may come.

eplwa-600-cropThree years later the Evergreen Premier League remains officially unconnected to any other state league. Wenatchee FC recently folded and a search is underway for a club to get the league back to 8. Meanwhile there were discussions about creating an “EPLWA 2” sort of league beneath the EPLWA that would have allowed statewide play for growing clubs to WSASA Logoprepare for higher play and travel. At some point such a league might have been under consideration as a partner for the EPLWA in promotion and relegation. The EPLWA AGM in Yakima on November 4 revealed that the league would focus on its current set-up and teams. The Washington Adult Soccer Association would look into the interest and feasibility of East and West regional leagues that might one day set a pathway to promotion and relegation.

cascadia_logo_2015-shadowIn the three years since the EPLWA was established, Cascadia Adult Soccer was born, associating itself with US Club Soccer (and FIFA, via US Club Soccer’s agreement with the United States Adult Soccer Association.) Cascadia Adult Soccer has a few adult men’s leagues under their umbrella, and a high-pedigree group that could oversee the fulfillment of Hamilton’s dream.

Promotion and relegation is a goal that not everyone, nor even every club, shares. Read Hamilton’s piece from 2013 and see if the bug bites you.

Promotion and Relegation in the ‘country’ of Washington

by Timothy S. Hamilton

September 2013

Denmark is my hero. Not just because of Legos, cheese danishes, and Hans Christian Andersen. They are a footballing nation to rival any on earth. They can boast winning both the EURO Cup and the Confederations Cup, as well as picking up three Olympic silver metals and a bronze. If that doesn’t sound too impressive, that’s one Confederations Cup and four Olympic metals more than the USA. Denmark also has an average world ranking of 17 since 1993. Again, that’s a full two places higher than the USA’s average ranking of 19. Still not impressed? Denmark has a population of 5.6 million. That’s 1.3 million less than Washington state.

ECL Divisions

Click to enlarge.

So how does a population smaller than Washington compete at a higher level than the USA? Simply put: they play a lot of football. Denmark has one of the most extensive domestic leagues in the world. The Superligaen may not be La Liga, Seria A, or the Premiership; yet the equivalent of one-fourth of the nation’s population attended the league last season. There isn’t a league in the USA that wouldn’t kill to say that. Yet the strength of Denmark’s football doesn’t just come from a strong first division. Below the Superligaen is series of increasingly more localized divisions connected via promotion/relegation. It is a seamless league from the rec level to the top professional level. That’s common around the world, except in the USA. All told, there are 2,383 teams playing in the Danish league. Between them they field some 511,000 players, over a fourth of the nations adult male population.

Timothy Hamilton, EPLWA Branding Manager.
Timothy Hamilton, EPLWA logo designer.

Impressive. Most impressive. But this is Washington, not Denmark. Enter the EPLWA, Washington’s first step into a larger soccer world. The league will début in 2014 with 8-10 teams competing in the first season. The formation of this league is a milestone for a number of reasons. First of all, it provides a valuable stepping-stone between rec leagues and national leagues. Not just for players, but for coaches, referees, and for clubs themselves. Right now the gap is astronomical. The EPLWA will close that gap on either side. Clubs, players, coaches, and referees will have a much easier time going from rec leagues to the EPLWA and from the EPLWA to a national league than they would trying to go straight to a national league. It will in a sense be a breeding ground from clubs and talent; a chance to prove themselves at a more competitive level. The league will also give a chance for many who probably wouldn’t continue their footballing careers to keep going. There is a lot of talent being wasted in this state simply because there aren’t enough opportunities to play competitively. The EPLWA will give late-bloomers and undiscovered talent a second chance. The league also gives supporters all around the state the opportunity of watching teams that represent their community. Communities which would otherwise need to support a team across the state, possibly in a rival community, or no team at all will finally have a team of their own. This will grow and cultivate supporter culture throughout the state. In short, the EPLWA is the first step towards making Washington a true soccer state.

EPLWA future structure

Click to enlarge graphic of four-division idea.

But it shouldn’t end there. The EPLWA is an important first step, but it is only a first step if soccer, and the EPLWA, want to be successful in this state. The strength of Denmark’s football prowess comes not only from the Superligaen but the structure of the lower division. The EPLWA will struggle over time without lower divisions to support it. In the first place, having new teams promoted and poorly performing teams relegated will keep the league from getting stagnant and predictable. Not only that, but it will increase competition in the bottom half of the table as teams fight for their lives. Secondly, it will provide a larger player pool for teams to choose from. Scouts will be able to watch lower division games and bring the best players into the EPLWA. Thirdly, it lets the best teams rise to the top over time. Teams that are poorly managed or can’t field competitive teams will drop. It always will allow the EPLWA to be populated with the best semi-pro teams in the state, not just the ones who signed up for the league first. Lower divisions will also give current rec and youth teams, or brand new teams, the opportunity to take smaller steps into the world of semi-pro soccer.

Superligaen logo.
Superligaen logo.

So what could the future of Washington soccer look like? Here’s one idea. And it can be implemented step by step. First step is the EPLWA, as I’ve already mentioned. The second step is to create a second division that is split into two divisions. For now let’s call them EPL WEST and EPL EAST. Teams would only play against teams in their division to minimize travel expenses and keep the cost of running the clubs down. At the end of each season the top teams of EPL WEST and EPL EAST enter a promotion playoff for a spot in next season’s EPLWA. Below this second division would be a third division, let’s call it the Evergreen Counties League (ECL), and it’s broken into six divisions. Again, each ECL division would be more local thus eliminating travel and keeping costs lower. Like the second division the top teams of each ECL division would playoff for a promotion spot in the EPL WEST or EAST. Below that would be the rec leagues, with the winners of each league earning the right to playoff for a promotion spot in the ECL division above them. Of course, in addition to promotion the worst team in each division would be sent down a level. This would create a seamless system of leagues within the state of Washington; a first for any state in the USA.

How the EPLWA develops over the next few years is, of course, largely up to the clubs, players, and supporters. But there is no reason Washington can’t build a system like that of Denmark over time. If it can, Washington will enjoy a strong and healthy soccer league for years to come, and could become my new hero.

Advertisements

One thought on “Revisiting the Promotion / Relegation ‘Hamilton Plan’ for Washington

Add yours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: